April 9th, 2002

Chalkboard

(no subject)

I liked this article and wanted to share it with you.

Emotion Pictures

Did Halle Berry's speech expose Oscar racism? At minimum, says Mark Harris, the criticism she's taking shows that pundits prefer their African-American actors to behave with restraint



On Sunday night, after 74 years, the Academy Awards finally caught up to the achievements of African-Americans. An honorary Oscar for Sidney Poitier, Best Actor to Denzel Washington, Best Actress to Halle Berry -- what a night.

On Monday morning, the commentary rolled in. Boy, do we still have a long way to go. And by ''we,'' I mean the very people -- professional pundits, Oscar-watchers, spinners, critics, and armchair quarterbacks -- who make up the peanut gallery that exhorted the Academy to right this wrong in the first place. Oscar may have changed -- at least for one night -- but some bad habits are hard to kill.

I'm talking in particular about the contrast being drawn between the emotionally coolheaded speeches of Poitier and Washington and the too-long, too-damp, over-too-many-tops Halle Berry Moment. Now, there's certainly no disputing the facts. Was Poitier his usual stentorian, immaculately controlled self? He was. Was Berry a little big for the room (even if the room had been Yankee Stadium)? Sure.

But I rankle when I start seeing words like ''dignity'' and ''restraint'' applied approvingly to African-American performers by mostly white writers. It rubs up against the notion that there's a right way and a wrong way for black people to behave in public. It says fettered is better. And in more than one case, it screams of a double standard.Collapse )